Insights

The Hardest Call Comes Before the Crisis

Written by Brian Besanceney, NACD.DC®, Principal Advisor at Alethea | Nov 17, 2026, 1:00:02 PM

I’ve sat in a lot of crisis war rooms, from the White House to three Fortune 50 companies.

For most of my career, a story had a starting gun: a reporter called, sent questions, and gave you time to respond. Now the first signal is often a creator with 4,000 followers saying your company quietly walked back a promise to customers, or a cluster of new accounts reviving a five-year-old complaint. No reporter has called, and your team still has to decide whether to respond, who needs to know, and whether saying anything will make it bigger.

The story starts somewhere else now

The Reuters Institute’s 2026 Digital News Report found that social and video platforms are now the most widely used source of news worldwide, used weekly by 54% of people and edging out TV at 52%. Nearly half get at least some news from creators. Creators remain a small share of what people consume, but they are often where a narrative first takes shape. By the time it reaches the outlets you track, your options have narrowed, and there’s no editor to call if a creator gets it wrong.

Some of these stories don’t start on their own. Short sellers, prediction market traders, and state actors all have reasons to give a narrative a push, and the tools to make a handful of voices look like a movement.

What the early decision needs

Twenty years ago, the first question in the war room was how confident we were in the facts. It still is. When the signal is small, the instinct is to ignore it or overreact. Today’s environment also adds questions we didn’t have to ask then:

  • What is this? The bottom line on the narrative, not a pile of mentions.
  • Who’s behind it? Real customers and advocates, or a coordinated effort with a motive.
  • Is it moving? How fast it’s growing, and which platforms and creators are carrying it.
  • What does it mean for us? Whether it crosses the line your organization has set for action.
  • What can we do? Whether a response helps or just feeds the algorithm, and who else needs to know.

Alethea built Artemis for Communications to answer those questions first, while a team still has the most options. The deeper analysis sits behind them for when you need it.

Most narratives don’t deserve a response

At the White House, I learned how much of the communications job is helping to prevent bad outcomes before they become public. The same holds in a corporate communications shop. Some of the best calls I made were decisions to stay quiet.

So I understand the worry I hear most from peers: if we see more, will we feel pressure to respond to more? It shouldn’t work that way, because responding to the wrong narrative gives it oxygen. A good early warning system helps a team decide what to leave alone.

In Artemis, your team sets its own threshold, matched to your organization’s risk tolerance and reputation strategy. Artemis informs the call. The people who know the business make it.

Boards are asking about this too. Last year, the DCRO Institute’s Reputation Risk Governance Council, which I served on, put it plainly in its guiding principles for directors: “Reputation risk is rarely a surprise. Signals often surface early—if the organization is listening.”

When it’s time to move early

When a narrative crosses the line, the goal is to act while it is still small and your options are still wide. Artemis keeps the intelligence and the response in one place. Teams can:

  • Brief leadership before they hear about it somewhere else, turning the narrative and bookmarked posts into a clear point of view.
  • Draft a holding statement before anyone asks for one, so the team can refine and approve it on its own timeline.
  • File takedown requests on violative content and choose how much of that to automate. Whether content comes down is the platform’s call, and takedowns alone rarely settle a narrative.
  • Spot threats of violence early, so comms can bring in security, legal, and, if warranted, law enforcement before anything escalates.

Often the best early move happens outside any platform: a call to the advocate, or a fix to the problem that started the conversation. Artemis gives a team the time and the facts to make that move.

What “from the start” looks like

Alethea’s team recently looked back at how one narrative about a brand’s animal-welfare commitment took shape, and Artemis reconstructed the full arc. It began with activists and niche influencers, online and in person, too small for most listening tools to notice. Larger influencers amplified it. A national advocacy group picked it up. Within 6 months, the brand accelerated its pledge.

Each step left a trail long before the pledge changed. A team that saw it early would have had months to talk with the advocates, brief leadership, and decide on its own timeline whether to move.

Built for communicators

Artemis was designed with comms teams. The bottom line comes first. Posts read like the social feeds your team already uses. Moving from a narrative to a decision to a briefing happens in one place, with no analyst background required. Underneath is the same collection and analysis Alethea’s intelligence teams use every day.

We'd love to show it to you! Request a demo here